Klopp’s Germany rebuild: Can he fix Nagelsmann’s mess?

Jürgen Klopp’s return to management was always going to be seismic. But the scale of the challenge facing him in Frankfurt is unlike anything he encountered at Liverpool. Appointed Germany head coach just days after Julian Nagelsmann’s resignation, Klopp inherits a national side still raw from a World Cup exit that felt like a national embarrassment. The DFB’s desperation was clear: they turned first to Klopp, bypassing more conventional candidates, because they needed a figure capable of restoring belief after Paraguay eliminated them in a penalty shootout. His first competitive test arrives on September 24 against the Netherlands in the Nations League, a fixture that will double as an early referendum on whether his magic can still work beyond club football.

Rebuilding a broken squad and a fractured identity

The roster Klopp inherits is a patchwork of unfulfilled potential. Nagelsmann’s final squad was exposed by tactical rigidity and a lack of cohesion, with key players either out of form or out of favour. Klopp’s immediate task is to identify who, if anyone, can still deliver under pressure. The DFB’s decision to pursue him over domestic alternatives suggests they believe his man-management—honed during nine transformative years at Anfield—can coax better performances from a group that has too often underachieved on the biggest stage. His first public remarks carried an unmistakable edge: he warned critics that he would walk away if his family were harassed, a sign of how seriously he takes the personal toll of the role. This is not a rebuilding project for the faint-hearted.

The squad’s overhaul will be the most visible change. Klopp’s Liverpool tenure thrived on adaptability, but international football demands a different kind of flexibility. Players like Jamal Musiala and Florian Wirtz need clearer roles, while veterans such as Toni Kroos—if he returns—must decide whether this is the swansong they envisioned. The DFB’s willingness to grant Klopp a four-year contract through to the 2030 World Cup signals long-term trust, but trust erodes quickly if results don’t follow. His first training camp will be scrutinised for signs of progress, not just in tactics, but in morale.

Tactical reset: Can Klopp’s Liverpool blueprint translate?

Klopp’s coaching philosophy is well documented, but national teams impose constraints he never faced at Liverpool. Squad depth is thinner, friendlies offer limited tactical rehearsal, and the window to implement change is brutally short. His Liverpool side relied on relentless pressing and vertical transitions, but Germany’s current personnel may not suit that model. The DFB’s recent struggles have been rooted in an inability to break down low blocks, a problem Klopp’s Liverpool often solved through individual brilliance rather than system tweaks. Whether he can recalibrate that balance in just eight weeks before the Nations League opener remains an open question.

The personnel dilemma is compounded by the absence of a clear leader. Unlike his Liverpool captains—Gerrard, Henderson, Van Dijk—Germany lacks a unifying voice in defence. Mats Hummels, once the rock of their 2014 triumph, is now 36 and peripheral. The midfield, once the envy of Europe, feels creaky, with Leon Goretzka and İlkay Gündoğan no longer the force they were. Klopp’s challenge is to either revive fading careers or gamble on younger options like Florian Wirtz, whose club form at Bayer Leverkusen has been inconsistent. The DFB’s recent flirtation with radical youth movements—reported here—suggests they’re open to disruption, but disruption without results is just chaos.

Pressure, scrutiny, and the weight of expectation

Klopp’s appointment comes at a time when German football is questioning its own identity. The DFB’s desperation was evident in their willingness to bypass Pep Guardiola, who turned down Italy after Manchester City’s exit, citing a lack of energy. Klopp, by contrast, insists he is “recharged,” but the role’s demands are uniquely gruelling. National team jobs offer little respite; every loss is a national trauma, every poor performance dissected in real time. His warning about walking away if his family is mistreated underscores the personal stakes. This is not a project for a manager seeking a quiet life.

The contrast with England’s post-Tuchel limbo is instructive. While Gareth Southgate’s future hangs by a thread, Klopp arrives with a clear mandate: qualify for Euro 2028 and restore pride. The DFB’s willingness to grant him a long-term deal reflects their belief that he can achieve both. But belief alone won’t win games. His first test will be the Nations League double-header against the Netherlands and France, fixtures that could expose the gulf between his ambitions and the current squad’s limitations. If Germany falter, the same voices that hailed Klopp as a saviour will turn on him with equal ferocity.

Klopp’s legacy at Liverpool was built on turning despair into triumph. Now he must do it again, but this time with a team that has forgotten how to win when it matters most. The road ahead is littered with obstacles, from tactical mismatches to the psychological scars of past failures. His success or failure will be measured not in trophies, but in whether he can make Germany believe in themselves again. The clock starts ticking on September 24.