Maresca’s City survive scare but remain a ‘work in progress’

Enzo Maresca’s first league win as Manchester City manager arrived in the 90th minute, not with the polished authority expected of a Guardiola successor, but through a frantic scramble that laid bare the club’s unfinished business. A side containing six players capable of playing in defence survived a Bournemouth side bristling with energy, only for Josko Gvardiol’s composed finish to spare blushes after Marc Guehi’s equaliser. The 2-1 victory preserved Maresca’s unbeaten start in charge, yet his post-match admission that “we are a work in progress” rang truer than any headline.

Maresca’s midfield roulette pays off—this time

Before kick-off, the talking point was whether Maresca would risk unsettling City’s rhythm with untested selections. Instead, he rolled the dice on Marc Guehi in an unfamiliar holding role, a decision that drew collective gasps from pundits and supporters alike. The former Crystal Palace captain had never played midfield regularly, yet he adapted quickly enough to score City’s first goal, shrugging off the positional oddity with a composed finish. “It was just an idea the manager had,” Guehi told Sky Sports. “We worked on it in the week. I’m glad today it paid off.”

Maresca’s willingness to experiment—even at the risk of backlash—reflects a manager unafraid to confront City’s midfield deficiencies head-on. His opening outing against Arsenal in the Community Shield had been startlingly bad, exposing gaps in both structure and composure. Against Bournemouth, those gaps resurfaced early: a loose clearance from Abdukodir Khusanov gifted Bournemouth the opener, while Ruben Dias’ failure to deal with a long ball compounded the chaos. By the 84th minute, City were staring at a second consecutive defeat before Guehi’s intervention.

Defensive fragility overshadows attacking promise

The backline’s shakiness was not confined to the opening goal. Rico Lewis, inverted from right-back, struggled to impose himself, while Khusanov’s error proved decisive. Even Dias, now captain, was culpable for Bournemouth’s opener, misjudging a cross-field ball that allowed Solly March to tease in Rayan. Donnarumma’s saves—denying Justin Kluivert’s low drive and Daniel Jebbison’s flicked header—prevented an even heavier scoreline, but his heroics masked systemic issues.

Up front, Erling Haaland’s struggles continued. The striker, sporting a fresh haircut, missed a sitter from close range and blazed another over in the second half. His lack of sharpness contrasted with Rayan Cherki’s cameo, introduced at half-time and immediately influential. The Frenchman provided two assists, including the cross for Gvardiol’s winner, underlining the gulf in creativity between the first and second halves. “Rayan changed the game,” one City source noted. “He gave us something different.”

Gvardiol’s moment of calm amid the storm

If City’s defensive lapses were alarming, Gvardiol’s composure under pressure was the counterbalance. The Croatian, deployed at left-back but drifting into midfield, was culpable for none of Bournemouth’s chances before rising to head Guehi’s cross past Neto in the 90th minute. His finish was clinical, a reminder that even in a chaotic display, City possess players capable of decisive interventions. “The Croatian was nowhere to be seen for Bournemouth’s goal before popping up to score a cool injury-time winner,” noted the BBC’s ratings.

Yet the manner of the win—two goals in the final six minutes—underscored Maresca’s central challenge: transforming a squad built for dominance into one capable of grinding out results when the game is not in their favour. The Community Shield defeat and this nervy escape suggest City are still a distance from the machine they were under Guardiola, a point Maresca acknowledged without equivocation.

Tactical reset needed before Palace trip

Maresca’s midfield gamble worked this time, but it is not a sustainable solution. Guehi’s deployment as a single pivot was a stopgap, not a blueprint, especially with Ayyoub Bouaddi’s arrival looming. The new signing’s arrival could force Guehi back to centre-back, where his ball-carrying and aerial ability are more valuable. Meanwhile, the absence of a natural defensive midfielder remains glaring. Elliot Anderson’s industry was welcome, but his limitations in possession retention were exposed.

City’s next test, at Crystal Palace on Friday, will reveal whether Maresca’s adjustments are temporary fixes or the foundations of a new system. The squad’s depth—particularly in midfield—will be tested further when Rodri returns from suspension. Until then, Maresca’s side remains a work in progress, capable of brilliance in patches but too inconsistent to inspire confidence.

For now, the points are safe. But the questions are louder than the celebrations. Maresca knows it. The players know it. And the fans, after two fraught weeks, are entitled to demand more than last-gasp escapes.