St Mirren’s shock start: How two wins defied relegation odds

St Mirren’s early-season surge: from play-off peril to Premiership pace-setters

St Mirren’s opening two fixtures have rewritten the script. After a tense play-off escape last May, the Paisley side were widely tipped for a relegation battle this term. Instead, they sit top of the Scottish Premiership with two clean sheets and a 100% record, a start that has already silenced pre-season doubts. The turnaround is built on a return to the defensive discipline and midfield control that defined their best campaigns under Stephen Robinson, now re-emerging under Craig McLeish’s “back to basics” mantra.

Defensive steel and midfield mastery underpin the rise

Two shutouts in two games would silence most critics, but St Mirren’s defensive organisation has done more than preserve clean sheets—it has set the tempo. Jacob Chapman’s penalty save against St Johnstone, his first major contribution since arriving in the summer, was the clearest sign that this team is determined to be “horrible to play against.” The new goalkeeper’s intervention came after a VAR review awarded St Johnstone a spot-kick, but the visitors’ inability to capitalise owed much to the visitors’ unfamiliarity with St Mirren’s intensity. Chapman’s reflexes were only the final layer; defenders threw themselves into challenges, attackers tracked back, and the collective effort reflected McLeish’s demand for relentless pressing and fitness.

That collective endeavour has been mirrored in midfield, where the balance between control and aggression has been decisive. Killian Phillips, the midfielder-turned-penalty specialist, has provided the cutting edge, scoring twice from the spot in as many matches. His second goal at SMiSA Stadium came after St Johnstone conceded a penalty for a foul on Samuel Ramos, a moment that underlined how St Mirren’s pressing can force errors from opponents. Phillips’ composure in front of goal has given McLeish’s side a late-game edge, while his industry in defence has helped shield the back four.

From play-off nerves to Premiership belief

The psychological shift is just as striking. Last season’s play-off agony—two fraught games that left nerves jangling even before the whistle—has been repurposed as motivation. McLeish has framed the disappointment as fuel, telling BBC Scotland: “I’m still using that as fuel. I don’t want to be involved in that.” The manager’s insistence on “fitness, energy, and desire” has translated into performances that feel like a return to the club’s competitive peak. Two wins from two have already fostered belief, but McLeish is careful not to overstate the scale of the task ahead: “Six points out of six is a great start… but we have a massive journey ahead.”

The contrast with last term’s fragility is stark. St Mirren’s survival was secured only after a nervy play-off against a lower-league side, a sequence that left supporters questioning whether the club could sustain top-flight football. This season, however, the squad’s depth and tactical clarity have allowed McLeish to rotate without sacrificing structure. The introduction of new faces like Chapman has added steel, while Phillips’ emergence as a penalty taker has given the team a reliable late-game option. Even when St Mirren lost Marcus Fraser to injury against St Johnstone, the defensive shape held, with Liam Donnelly slotting in seamlessly.

Tactical template: pressing, structure, and set-piece discipline

St Mirren’s approach is built on three pillars: high pressing, compact midfield organisation, and set-piece efficiency. The pressing triggers are clear—once possession is lost, attackers immediately harry the ball-carrier, while midfielders drop into channels to cut passing lanes. Against St Johnstone, this forced errors in dangerous areas, culminating in the penalty that Phillips converted. The team’s willingness to defend in numbers has also neutralised opponents’ attacking transitions, a habit that contrasts sharply with last season’s reactive displays.

In possession, St Mirren prioritise quick transitions and direct play into channels, using Phillips and Alex Gogic as outlets to relieve pressure. The full-backs push high when the ball is in advanced positions, but they are quick to recover when possession is turned over. Set-pieces, often a weakness in previous campaigns, have been executed with precision; Phillips’ second goal arrived from a penalty won by Ramos’ intelligent run into the box, a reminder that even dead-ball situations are treated as opportunities rather than risks.

McLeish’s insistence on “not getting bored” of the basics has bred a team that looks fitter and more cohesive than at any point since Robinson’s departure. The manager’s message—”We want to be really good at the basics”—has translated into performances that feel sustainable, not reliant on individual brilliance.

A title race in miniature?

Two games do not a title decide, but St Mirren’s start has already shifted the narrative. The club that was once a relegation cert has become a team capable of setting the agenda. Their next test comes against a side that also began strongly—Aberdeen stunned Hearts with stoppage-time strikes in their opener, a result that briefly put the Dons top of the table. That match underlined how competitive the Premiership is this season, but St Mirren’s defensive resilience and midfield steel give them a platform to compete with anyone.

For now, the focus remains on maintaining the momentum. McLeish’s side have shown they can grind out results, but the real challenge will be sustaining this intensity across 38 games. If they can, the play-off scars of last season may yet become the foundation for something far greater.